own-age.com » Videos » Dude, where's my railgun?

Add a review here

Page 1 of 1

bacchus

Site Admin

Join Date: 11/12/2002
Posts: 4322

Review by bacchus

Summary:
Good vid. Not very original, light editing, but worth the download for the original nice rail shots.

Creativity: 5
Nothing really original here, except that the vid is mainly focused on nice rail shots.

Editing: 6
Editing was simple, but efficient. No recam. Scoreplums should have been turned to 0. A very few effects nicely done. Maybe more effort put into editing would have been better. Sync was bad (sometimes ingame sounds and action were really badly sync'ed, hope it comes from me).
The idea of displyin the kind of frgas in the right bottom of the screen was original, but I didn't like the idea. Could be good if it helped to follow action but it was not needed here and it only distracts from the vid itself.
I didn't really like the intro (the part were the guy is running through a map), but credits were rather short, and I prefer that to a long rolling text with nothing else.

Content: 7
Some really nice rail shots. A few nice arishots too, but most of the non-rail shots had nothing special. And it was always the same map(s).

Quality: 8
Quality was good, it is under the 20megs/min limit (around 18 in fact here), and really nothing to complain about on that point. Good job for that.

Overall: 6
Always the same map, basic editing, rather common shots (apart the rail shots)...
But a vid I recommend to watch for the rail shots, especially because there are less and less Q3 frag vids...

IP: Logged

Posted: 8.14.04 @ 4:03 PM

fei

Regular User

Join Date: 7/14/2003
Posts: 1846

Review by fei

Summary:
firma got his frag vid, and the shots impress...

Creativity: 3
+credits were nice

-no new sexy effect from joka this time

Editing: 6
-intro had no feeling, and the forcemodels never look good to me.

-red tint and some off synce in parts

-nothing new

+the zoom for the footshot rail was nicely done

Content: 8
you can't say there wasn't a few amazing shots in this, one of the best single player frag vids for that. few shots were added just for the you fragged cooller mesage and a few so-so shots but overall above average.

personly didnt like the music and hoobastank has been used few times but music is opinion.

Quality: 6
quality was on the low side.

Overall: 6
content keep this vid alive, to bad i seen all the demo before :D

nutshell: a good q3 frag vid.

IP: Logged
Modified by IP: Logged

Posted: 8.11.04 @ 9:16 PM
Last modified: 8.13.04 @ 7:20 AM

spawnsen

Regular User

Join Date: 12/6/2003
Posts: 495

Review by spawnsen

Summary:
best-of-fragvid without eyecandy

Creativity: 5
i couldnt find anything brandnew here

Editing: 5
mostly standard stuff and filters
scroreplums may couldve been set to 0
only a few little mistakes with the nme model
nearly no synching

Content: 8
really nice frag, flickshots and airhits
but 7minutes ztn only bores me

Quality: 8
quality was suitable

Overall: 6
quit a good fragvid, the frags are worth the dl :>

IP: Logged

Posted: 8.11.04 @ 6:05 PM

Page 1 of 1

Add a review here