own-age.com » Videos » Clueka : Mini Movie

Add a review here

Page 1 of 1

jegHegy

Regular User

Join Date: 6/30/2004
Posts: 42

Review by jegHegy

Summary:
could be better, but nice start :)

Creativity: 6
i liked how the title's font matches the cel-shaded looks of the map in the intro.

Editing: 6
effects were ok (with some syncing), but the transitions between clips seem random except when the second song starts.

Content: 6
well, it's kinda hard to show something new when it comes to q3 tricking, so yeah. the config could use some work, you can see a lot of jaggies.

Quality: 5
video quality was ok unless you look at it from close :) audio quality wasn't too good, mp3 artifacts all over the songs :(

Overall: 6
pretty nice start, although a bit short for three songs -- they end too suddenly. intro and outro too long for the amount of content between them.

IP: Logged

Posted: 8.14.04 @ 3:57 AM

fei

Regular User

Join Date: 7/14/2003
Posts: 1846

Review by fei

Summary:
short first vid, not bad

Creativity: 2
sarge-doom was about as creative as this got :D

Editing: 7
nothing to really complain about, yet nothing groundbreaking. good job for a first vid.

Content: 6
tricks were better then what i can do yet not iT level. to short, not enough tricks for me

Quality: 5
grainy and jagged. work on your capture methods and quality settings in game and in your vid card drivers. look around on the fourms.

Overall: 5
at 4min its not a waste of time, and the music gave it a nice feel. had a "over already feel" when the creadits came up so it wasn't bad at all. but to stand in the q3 trick crowd you need some amazing tricks and editing...

IP: Logged

Posted: 8.13.04 @ 1:50 PM

Page 1 of 1

Add a review here